the danceview times
writers on dancing
Ballet and dance reviews from New York, San Francisco, and Washington, D.C.


 Volume 3, Number 33  September 12, 2005     The weekly online supplement to DanceView magazine

Welcome Visitors

Sasha Waltz and Guests
August 15 & 16, 2005

"The Grey Area," "La Valse," "The Concert"
Dutch National Ballet
September 1-3, 2005
Edinburgh Playhouse
Edinburgh, Scotland
by John Percival
copyright ©2005 by John Percival

Time was that the annual Edinburgh Festival might have different major ballet companies filling its three weeks—I recall for instance Sadler’s Wells, New York City and Cuevas in succession playing six nights each, plus matinees.  That practice has long gone, and some directors over the years have almost ignored dance.

The present head man, Sir Brian McMaster, goes in for short, varied engagements by companies of different size and quality.   There are gaps between, but assiduous dance fans can find much more activity than in earlier years in the independent and overlapping Fringe Festival.

This year I saw three out of five official presentations, involving two visits (a six-hour journey each way; the trains used to be quicker). I’ve already reported on the Pennsylvania Ballet’s disappointing “Swan Lake” which opened the Festival; a recompense on that trip was catching Sasha Waltz’s “Impromptus”.  Created in April 2004 at her usual base, the Schaubuehne am Lehniner Platz, Berlin, this is set, unusually for Waltz, to lyrical 19th-century music played live, which has encouraged her to a far more dance-filled structure. The music in question is by Franz Schubert: five piano impromptus played by Christina Marton and four songs by Judith Simonis, mezzo-soprano; these musicians, at the side of the large stage, managed to sound good even in Edinburgh’s vast, dreary Playhouse.
read review

Disappointing Visitors

National Ballet of Cuba
August 16-21, 2005
“Revelations”, “Caught”, “Solo”, “Shining Star”, “Reminiscin’ ”
Alvin Ailey American Dance Theatre
Sadler’s Wells Theatre
London, England
September 5-10, 2005
by John Percival
copyright ©2005 by John Percival

Looking for something else, I came across my review of the Cuban National Ballet’s British debut a quarter-century ago, and discovered that I did not wholly like the company.  And that remains true on subsequent visits, including this year’s trip to Sadler’s Wells. Why am I out of step with much critical and public opinion?

I do recognise that Cuba produces many outstanding classical dancers. Unfortunately many of the best move overseas as soon as they can, seeking a more rewarding repertoire and better pay too.  Judging by my one visit this time, the general level is perfectly presentable but I didn’t see any real star dancing. The other problem is (as I’ve already hinted) the repertoire. This is dominated by the classics as staged by their founder-director Alicia Alonso.  They opened with a mixed bill: snippets from “Giselle”, “Sleeping Beauty”, “Nutcracker”, “Coppelia, “Don Quixote” and “Swan Lake” Act 2, plus the finale from “Gottschalk Symphony”—also by Alonso.  I’m told this last was quite entertaining (I couldn’t see this programme—in Edinburgh on the press night, and the only other performance was completely sold out.  Reliable opinions were that the standards of dancing varied—some good, some less so. But I’ve seen various Alonso productions and am not convinced about her command of the classics.
read review

Dancing on the
Shoulders of Giants

"Dance Inspired By Dance"
Daniel Burkholder / The Playground
Millennium Stage North
John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts
Washington, DC, USA
Thursday, September 1, 2005
by George Jackson
copyright ©2005 by George Jackson

There was commonality and contrast. Both of the Daniel Burkholder pieces that comprised this program referred to the choreographic canon, yet they were refreshingly different. "Horizon Light: an appalachian spring" was, visually, about bodies and the sculptural and dramatic movement they can generate. This work came first and, of course, had the Martha Graham / Aaron Copland / Isamu Noguchi classic in mind. The second piece, "together / apart (we go each our way)" alluded to Twyla Tharp's "Nine Sinatra Songs" which is well on its way to becoming iconic, especially in the videotaped version with Tharp herself and Mikhail Baryshnikov. In this latter Burkholder dance, Chris Dalen's costumes—broad horizontal stripes, loose contours and unisex cuts—negated the bodies that wore them so that the choreographer's emphasis on dynamics and pacing emerged almost as incorporeal energy. Dalen's costumes for the opener were also unisex, but being tighter revealed more about the dancers—including Mr. Burkholder's gain of weight.  
read review

Meandering Repetition

Francesca Selva Dance Company
Danspace Project's Dance:Access Series
St. Mark's Church
New York
September 9, 2005

by Susan Reiter
copyright ©2005 by Susan Reiter

There was an air of grim determination from the start of Francesca Selva's shapeless, disappointing two-part "Camminando-XYZ" that remained throughout the ninety-minute work. The four dancers performed their appointed tasks with such a dour air that the dance took on the atmosphere of an assignment to be gotten through. Certainly, the overall vagueness and lack of focus in Selva's choreography—with its bland mix of cleanly executed ballet steps ( plenty of arabesques and jetes) with generic, swoopy partnering and uninspired floor sequences—did not give them much to work with.

Selva's ten-year-old troupe is based in Siena, Italy. Her background includes training at the ballet school at La Scala and studies in France with a variety of teachers, including Rosella Hightower, and early in her career she danced with Roland Petit's Ballet de Marseille. The two men and two women performing in this piece clearly were ballet-trained, and the women had lovely line in arabesque, but Selva mixes in elements of ballet within a more generalized, matter-of-fact contemporary approach.
read review

Burlesque Tonight

"The Adventures of Cunning and Guile"
Chris Black and Ken James
Cartoon Art Museum
655 Mission Street (at 3rd)
San Francisco, California
September 9, 2005
by Paul Parish
copyright ©2005 by Paul Parish

Chris Black and Ken James are, respectively, Cunning and Guile—unless I've got them backwards (it's anyway the same difference). They wear identical jeans and long-sleeved grey T-shirts (designed by Lark Pien), differentiated only by the initials "C" and "G" where otherwise a Superman logo might ride. At times they don sweatshirts that spell out their full names, and each carries a 1940's-style leather suitcase fitted with the sound and lighting effects their act is going to require. They top it off with Buster-Keatonish dead pans.

Black and James have separate modern-dance companies ("Potrzebie" and "Fellow Travellers," respectively). They've been performing together since 1992, usually in poker-faced comic material that's sometimes too clever by half. Their latest outing, "The Adventures of Cunning and Guile," is the outgrowth of a brilliant, exquisite number they showed at one of ODC's "House Specials" in 2001, just after the attacks on the World Trade Center (when we all needed to see something composed of lightning-fast, perfectly timed mayhem performed by people who looked like they might be Democrats).
read review

Women in Skirts

Trey McIntyre Project
Doris Duke Studio Theater
Jacob's Pillow Dance Festival
Becket, MA
Saturday August 13, 2005 (matinee)
by Susan Reiter
copyright ©2005 by Susan Reiter

Trey McIntyre seems to really appreciate women in skirts. No body stockings, or the hint of anything unisex, for him. In each of the three recent works on the debut program of his Trey McIntyre Project, the women wore shapely, carefully designed costumes that were highly feminine. Some of the costuming was distracting, even problematic, but it always made a bold statement, and reflected a determined, individual artistic mind at work.

This venture was essentially a summer pick-up group, consisting of ten dancers from various established companies whom the busy freelance choreographer had worked with on earlier projects, that rehearsed and performed during July and August. The week of performances at Jacob's Pillow was its finale, following appearances in Colorado and Idaho. All indications are that McIntyre is serious about making it an ongoing enterprise, even if for the moment it must be fit into his busy, peripatetic freelance work.  An elegant, substantial color brochure outlining his background and goals; a rehearsal period at the Howard Gilman Foundation's White Oak Plantation; support from the Jerome Robbins Foundation—this troupe is clearly no momentary, fly-by-night venture.
read review

Moving to the Music

Dance Theater Workshop
New York, New York
September 8, 2005
by Tom Phillips
copyright ©2005 by Tom Phillips

In a provocative essay last week (9/6) in The New York Times, Gia Kourlas wrote “New York is no longer the capital of the contemporary dance world.”  Creative energy has shifted abroad, she said, and “Europe is becoming what New York used to be.”  As a proud and provincial New Yorker, I was shocked.  So when Dance Theater Workshop presented an evening of young choreographers, on the second night of the season-opening DancenOw/NYC festival, I went looking for evidence to refute this crazy charge. Truth to tell, I found as much to support as to contradict it.
read review


"Dancing Bournonville"
Royal Danish Ballet, Scottish Ballet, Ballet Rambert, London Festival Ballet
National Film Theatre
London, England
August 2-31, 2005

“Highland Fling”
New Adventures
Sadler’s Wells Theatre, London
August 26 – September 3, 2005
by John Percival
copyright ©2005 by John Percival

Following its seasons commemorating Rudolf Nureyev ten years after his death and George Balanchine on his centenary, London’s National Film Theatre has come up with a bicentennial celebration under the title “Dancing Bournonville”. This comprised four programmes, each shown twice, spread through the month of August.

The opening bill was fascinating for its inclusion of ten short films made a whole century ago, in 1902-06, by the Court photographer Peter Elfelt using, amazingly, a camera he made himself, by hand, from his sketch of one seen at the Paris Exposition. Of course they were made in silence, but a piano accompaniment by Elvi Henriksen has been added, and the film is projected in a version with every second frame printed twice to alleviate the flickery effect usual in early movies.  It’s great to see fragments from “La Sylphide”, “The King’s Volunteers” and “Napoli” given by such historic names as Ellen Price, Valborg Borchsenius and Hans Beck, but perhaps even more so to catch unknown dances from “Il Trovatore” etc. including numbers by Beck and Poul Funck (who he, you may ask—I certainly did).
read review

Emotion in Slow Motion

"The Water Station"
Pacific Performance Project
HERE Arts Center
New York, New York
September 10, 2005
by Lisa Rinehart
copyright ©2005 by Lisa Rinehart

Amidst the cacophony of the classroom, teachers of young children know that whispering has the effect of surprising them into a heightened state of alertness. Shogo Ohta, the minimalist playwrite, uses the same technique in his play "The Water Station" (Mizu no Eki) presented by the Pacific Performance Project (P3) at the HERE Arts Center. The play is performed without spoken text and in mesmerizing slow motion. Ohta states, "The fact of human presence implies the presence of life and of consciousness," and that action in adagio allows us to go beyond the familiar act of looking and achieve the philosophical experience of seeing. And indeed, this is what happens in this beautiful and powerful play. As the actors walk, kneel, and drink from a perpetually running water spigot, our attention is gently seized by the beauty of their mundane movements. We are compelled to look closer at their faces and body language. What we see is a universe of human emotion condensed into a look over the shoulder, a hand drawn to the face, or a bit of hair pulled in distraction.
read review

To find out how you can support this site, click here.

Search this site or
the web powered by FreeFind

Site search Web search

What's On This Week
Index of Reviews
Index of Writers

Back Issues
About Us



Mindy Aloff
Dale Brauner
Mary Cargill
Christopher Correa
Clare Croft
Nancy Dalva
Rita Felciano
Marc Haegeman
George Jackson
Eva Kistrup
Gia Kourlas
Alan M. Kriegsman
Sali Ann Kriegsman
Alexander Meinertz
Gay Morris
Ann Murphy
Paul Parish
John Percival
Tom Phillips
Susan Reiter
Lisa Rinehart
Jane Simpson
Alexandra Tomalonis(Editor)
Lisa Traiger
Kathrine Sorley Walker
Leigh Witchel
David Vaughan


The Summer Issue of DanceView is OUT!
(our subscription link is once again functional, so it's easy to subscribe on line)


ABT's Spring Season, reviewed by Mary Cargill

"On Frederick Ashton's Brand of Classicism," by Michael Popkin

NYCB's Spring Season, reviewed by Tom Phillips

Miami City Ballet's spring season, reviewed by Carol Pardo

National Ballet of Canada's 2005-2006 season, reviewed by Denise Sum

Reports from London (Jane Simpson), New York (Gay Morris) and San Francisco (Rita Felciano)

This site is the online supplement to DanceView, a quarterly review of dance published since 1979.

DanceView is available by subscription ONLY. Don't miss it. It's a good read.  Black and white, 48 pages, no ads. Subscribe today!



Copyright © 2005 by DanceView
last updated on September 12, 2005